Nowadays, I don’t feel that way about psychiatry. I’m not saying that Laing, Goffman, Szasz etc didn’t get anything right. Of course they did, and to some degree yes, mental illness is a social construct designed to deal with ways of thinking and behaving that society finds disturbing or unacceptable. And yes, the history of psychiatry is one riddled with stories of neglect and abuse.
But…and here comes the big But…well, the author of Pole to Polar: The Secret Life of a Manic Depressive has put it perfectly:
All I want, all I believe, is that bipolar disorder is real. As for the medications? If you make informed decisions and are supported, and if they help you, that’s the important thing. I am sick of the anti-med bandwagon. I rolled on it for such a long time. The churlish, “ddddduuuuh mental illness is fake!” belief just reinforces the stigma of mental illness. The most important thing to me is that people with mental illness, behavioural disorders, whatever the hell you want to call it, aren’t marginalised and discriminated against for something that- yes, even if they’re aware of it- feels out of their control. I have said time and time again here that I always felt that what was happening to me was biological. I fought the good fight. I went on the diets. Changed my scene. Did the mindfullness techniques. Had the therapy. Stopped the booze. Settled down and lived a quiet, careful life. And I am still a manic depressive. I still suffer intense depression. I still suffer highs and mixed episodes. And I even have the “broken home”, the “unstable background”. And yet, I’m okay with that. My broken home and unstable background is populated with people and experiences I cherish. It didn’t destroy me. It never will.
I don’t care if they’re a cluster of symptoms defined in an outdated manual. To me, they are real. They do not define me as a person. And knowing that, hanging on to that, is what gets me through when I feel I am losing the fight.



Recent Comments